Nicks Golden Pizza and More

Nestled in the heart of Shrewsbury, MA, Nicks Golden Pizza and More offers a delightful blend of classic American and Italian comfort foods that will satisfy every craving. This family-owned pizza restaurant excels in crafting a diverse menu that goes way beyond your average pie, inviting both locals and visitors to indulge in authentic, hearty meals served with genuine warmth and care.

From the moment you step into their cozy space at 271 Grafton St, you’re enveloped in an inviting, no-fuss atmosphere that feels like a friend's kitchen—small but with enough tables to enjoy a quick sit-down. Whether you’re seeking a fast pickup or a casual place to savor a comforting meal, Nick’s Golden Pizza and More hits just the right spot.

Their pizza offerings truly shine with thoughtfully crafted combinations such as the savory Meat Lovers and the crisp-edge Cheese and Pepperoni Thin Crust. Fans of the classics will appreciate the robust flavors in the Pepperoni and Olives or Pepperoni and Green Bell Peppers, each delivering the right balance between tangy tomato sauce, melty mozzarella, and generous toppings. For those with specialized needs, the restaurant serves arguably the best gluten-free pizza dough in Massachusetts, praised for its quality and texture—a must-try for anyone avoiding gluten.

But Nick’s is far from a one-trick pony. Their menu also features tender, crispy Chicken Wings that burst with flavor and a satisfyingly golden-crisp Fish and Chips Fried Haddock that tastes like a seaside retreat. Those looking for fresh, wholesome bites will find comfort in their crisp Antipasto Salad Tray or the vibrant Cobb Salad, packed with grilled chicken, boiled egg, creamy avocado, and a bright balsamic vinaigrette that awakens the palate.

Not to be missed is their Signature Garlic Cheese Bread, a perfect combination of buttery garlic richness and gooey cheese—a side that feels like a hug in every bite. For a touch of Mediterranean flair, try the Mom’s Dolma Stuffed Grape Leaves, deliciously tender and served with refreshing tzatziki and garlic breadsticks—beautifully blending tastes and textures.

Nicks Golden Pizza and More finishes the experience with a tempting array of desserts. The Baklava offers a perfectly sweet crunch layered with nuts, while the creamy New York Baked Cheesecake stands out as an indulgent, velvety treat. For a fun, nostalgic option, their Fried Oreos, dusted in powdered sugar, bring a playful end to any meal.

The friendly and attentive staff, including owner Nick and team members like Kristen, make every visit feel personalized and welcoming. The genuine hospitality adds warmth to every interaction, making dining at Nicks not just about great food but also about feeling at home. Whether you're dropping by to grab a quick, delicious bite or settling in for a casual meal with friends, this gem in Shrewsbury offers a memorable and satisfying experience.

With consistently high praises for both the food and service, Nicks Golden Pizza and More is a must-visit for anyone craving thoughtfully prepared comfort food with a side of hometown charm.